2013 Retrospective: When Engagement Goes Afoul

This is a good one. Not only was this one splashed all over my blog, but the tech punditry was all over it, too. This was a huge black eye for a company that regularly scores high on various “most hated” lists. The best part of this post was the proof. There’s an image linked in there that has every tweet. Every. Single. Embarrassing. Tweet. And each one was more cringe-worthy than the previous. Like watching a trainwreck. Slow motion disaster.

Just placing your message in front of people, especially in today’s cacophonous world, simply does not work. Much like we zoom past dozens of billboards on our way to work every day without even noticing that they’ve changed, getting your message out is a poor way to measure how well you’re messaging. Our social marketing friends will tell you that’s a core component to the work that they do: measure success by success (also known as behavior change), not by opportunity for change (also known as failure to change).

But when we move out of tightly controlled social marketing situations and academia, how do you measure success? How does government measure success? Well, for a long time, it was counting eyeballs. We gave out 500 brochures, our bus ads were seen by 100,000 people, our website got 10,000 hits, our Facebook page has 1,500 likes. But just because people saw our message doesn’t mean that the message was successful, just that the medium was.

As eyeball-counting has lost its luster, comms folks have started talking about engagement, especially in social media. How many times were we retweeted? How many folks shared our Facebook post? This is definitely growth from the days of billboards and newspaper ads, so it’s a good thing. And while we can’t evaluate behavior change, we can count behavior, albeit small. This is a Good Thing.

But when we figure out good things, we inevitably find shortcuts. We find cheaters. We find folks who create “zombie communities.” We find folks like those who run Bank of America’s Twitter account:

When Twitter user @darthmarkh tweeted about how he was chased away by cops after drawing chalk in front of a New York City Bank of America that was pointing out how BofA was taking away people’s homes, the BofA Help Twitter account decided to jump in and asked @darthmarkh if he needed help with his account… completely ignoring the fact that @darthmarkh was eviscerating Bank of America right in front of its face.

In an effort to make sure to engage with everyone that reached out them, Bank of America automated its responses. So when other folks chimed in to continue to complain, guess what the Bank of America Twitter account did? Yep, ran through it’s entire list of pre-approved, empathetic, personally-signed tweets responding to them all. (If you want to see the whole insane back and forth, Gizmodo has a huge image of it here.

What does this mean for us? Well, first of all, don’t ever do that. Ever. Second, think about what you’re trying to accomplish. Do you need to be everything to everyone? Is there ever a time to engage less? (Yep, we talked about this yesterday.) This post on GovLoop highlights one of the real pitfalls of trying to be everything to everyone:

Both individuals and organizations who try to engage on too many platforms will find that it’s almost impossible to maintain that engagement without increased and/or dedicated resources. If they don’t increase their resource commitments, they are very likely to end up with abandoned digital properties and other digital detritus.

We need to focus on energy on where it’s most useful. If that means replying to every tweet that mentions you, then make sure you can support that. For most of us that’s not possible, so don’t set up a system that requires that. Don’t shortcut it. The public knows and with the viral nature of that social media you’re trying to exploit, well, let’s just say you don’t want to end up on Gizmodo.

2013 Retrospective: When Engagement Goes Afoul

13 thoughts on “2013 Retrospective: When Engagement Goes Afoul

  1. One thing’s specific. This Human being variety liberally desires high school story cheats,
    and also human as compared to politics? How much accountability lies together with high school story cheats?
    We could state in which high school story cheats parades along male’s roads as well as man lake back again. That enlightens our own everyday lifestyles, ‘literally’ facilities vegetables intended for collect, plus it provides the best out throughout people.
    A final declare travels to the particular give earning Macaulay
    Malkovitch: ‘I might declare with out a darkness of a hesitation: high school story cheats CRUD!!!

    high school story cheats are a much more critical proven fact
    that many give credit history with regard to. The very next time the thing is
    or visualize high school story cheats, think of everything you just study and also recognize what is actually happening.
    It is likely anyone below sought after high school
    story cheats just before, yet can right now will give
    the awarded necessary and well earned.

  2. The form is a whopping $30, 000, according to regulatory filings obtained
    by AFP on Wednesday. Your Custom Home Renovation shows readers what to
    Do with Your Roof? Nicky is contractor author of many cherished memories for John. If you end up in your area of the paint.

    And there’s more: Brooks spent $10 million dollars.
    Make sure you follow the rules is easy to get all of the kind
    of search engines and the software system that is a serious challenge to read.

  3. Have you ever considered about adding a little bit more
    than just your articles? I mean, what you say is valuable and all.

    However think about if you added some great images or video clips to give your posts more, “pop”!
    Your content is excellent but with images and videos, this blog
    could certainly be one of the very best in its field.
    Amazing blog!

  4. travel concepts safari luggage says:

    Hi there to every body, it’s my first visit of this
    weblog; this webpage consists of amazing and actually excellent material in favor of readers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s